A new study by Dental.me found that artificial intelligence assistants frequently recommended dental offices that were closed when asked to identify emergency dental care available late at night. According to the company’s findings, 69% of recommended locations with verifiable posted hours were closed at the time of the inquiry.
The study evaluated ChatGPT, Google’s Gemini, and Anthropic’s Claude across the 50 largest U.S. cities on November 14, 2026. Researchers asked each assistant to identify three specific dental offices, including phone numbers, that were open at the time to treat a patient experiencing a toothache.
The testing took place between 10:43 p.m. and 11:04 p.m. Eastern time, with each inquiry submitted before midnight in the corresponding city. Researchers used fresh sessions for each assistant and compared the recommendations with Google Maps listings and posted operating hours.
Across 150 responses, the assistants recommended 600 locations or services. Of the 248 recommended locations whose posted operating hours could be checked, 170 (69%) were closed at the time of the inquiry. Dental.me reported closed-office recommendation rates of 43% for ChatGPT, 54% for Claude, and 97% for Gemini.
According to the study, 48 of the 50 cities had at least one recommendation for a closed location. In 93 of the 150 responses, researchers could not confirm that any recommended dental office was open, excluding hospital emergency departments.
The study also examined recommendations described as offering 24-hour service. Of 201 dental offices identified by the assistants as open 24 hours, only 65 could be confirmed open. Another 46 were closed according to their posted Google hours, while 45 could not be located on Google Maps.
Researchers reported that 61 recommended locations had no matching Google Maps listing under the names, addresses, or telephone numbers provided. Of these, 36 were generated by ChatGPT.
Five recommendations identified individual dentists whose names could not be verified in the federal National Provider Identifier registry for the states in which they were reportedly practicing. According to Dental.me, four of those names had no corresponding dentist registered anywhere in the United States. The fifth matched a dentist registered in another state.
The researchers also found that some recommendations did not identify dental practices. Among the 600 locations or services named, 112 were hospital emergency departments and 70 were hotlines or referral services.
“A toothache doesn’t wait for Monday morning, and late at night is exactly when people turn to an AI for help,” said Spencer Whiteclaw, head research analyst at Dental.me. “We asked for a dentist who was open right now, and seven times out of ten the office we could check was closed. Some of the dentists we were sent to could not be found anywhere, not on a map and not in the federal provider registry. When you are in pain at ten o’clock at night, a confident answer that sends you to a locked door, or to a dentist no one can find, is worse than no answer at all. Call before you drive.”
The study noted that the AI assistants sometimes included cautions about availability. In 49 recommendations involving closed offices, the responses acknowledged that the location might be closed or would reopen the following morning. Gemini frequently suggested hospital emergency departments or on-call services.
Dental.me determined office availability using the posted Google hours applicable to each location at the time of the inquiry, rather than subsequently displayed business status information. The researchers acknowledged that some practices may offer after-hours telephone services even when their offices are closed.
For dental practices, the findings raise questions about the reliability of AI-generated information used to locate emergency dental services, particularly when patients seek care outside regular business hours. The study evaluated the accuracy of recommendations and did not assess the clinical quality of the practices identified.
Dental.me operates a national dental directory that evaluates more than 245,000 U.S. dental practices using public records and patient review information. The company states that its scoring system applies a consistent published methodology across practices.